policy

Labor Dept. Warns Health Plans Over Inaccurate Provider Directories

Summarized from DOL News Releases and Briefs

A federal survey found 36% of provider directory listings were wrong, exposing workers to surprise out-of-network costs.

Labor Dept. Warns Health Plans Over Inaccurate Provider Directories

The U.S. Department of Labor on Wednesday issued an enforcement alert directing employers and health plan fiduciaries to ensure their provider directories are accurate and regularly updated, citing widespread errors that can saddle workers with unexpected medical bills.

An undercover survey by the department's Employee Benefits Security Administration, in which investigators called more than 27,000 providers across 27 health networks, found that more than a third of directory listings contained incorrect information. The findings underscore a persistent gap between what plan documents promise and what enrollees actually encounter when seeking care.

Read more OSHA Fines NJ Bakery, Staffing Agency $351K After Two Conveyor Injuries →

The problem runs deeper than simple data errors. Using what EBSA called a "pathway to service metric" — measuring whether a listed provider could be reached, confirmed as in-network, and seen within 30 days — 66% of medical and surgical providers failed to meet all three criteria. Among mental health and substance use disorder providers, the failure rate climbed to 74%, a figure that carries particular weight amid ongoing national concern over access to behavioral health services.

Under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act and the No Surprises Act, health plans are legally required to verify and publish current provider information. The enforcement alert spells out fiduciary obligations, reproduces additional survey findings, and provides specific questions employers should put to their insurance carriers and third-party administrators to gauge how directories are maintained.

Secretary of Labor Keith Sonderling framed the guidance as a consumer-protection measure, stating that plans and insurers "must do better" in giving workers the information needed to make informed healthcare decisions. Employers and plan participants seeking assistance can contact EBSA at askebsa.dol.gov or by calling 866-444-3272. Continue reading at DOL News Releases and Briefs.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q.What did the Labor Department's survey find about health provider directories?

An EBSA secret shopper survey of more than 27,000 providers across 27 networks found that 36% of provider directory information was incorrect, potentially exposing plan participants to unexpected out-of-network costs.

Q.What is the 'pathway to service metric' used by the Labor Department?

The pathway to service metric evaluates whether a listed provider can be contacted, confirmed as in-network, and is accepting new patients within 30 days. Sixty-six percent of medical and surgical providers and 74% of mental health providers failed to meet all three criteria.

Q.What laws require health plans to maintain accurate provider directories?

Health plans and insurance issuers are required under the Employee Retirement Income Security Act and the No Surprises Act to regularly verify, update, and publish accurate provider directory information.

More in policy →